Indignation over the destruction and plundering of Iraqi cultural artifacts has turned into accusations that the United States shirked its responsibilities. But the damage can no longer be undone.
People have been enraged worldwide by U.S. Defense Minister Donald Rumsfeld’s seemingly callous remarks last Friday, accusing the media of exaggerating the looting of Iraqi cultural treasures.
“The images you are seeing on television you are seeing over and over,” he said, “and it’s the same picture of some person walking out of some building with a vase, and you see it 20 times, and you think, ‘My goodness, were there that many vases? Is it possible that there were that many vases in the whole country?’”
There were more than 20 vases in Iraq.
Shock at the images of the looted National Museum in Baghdad, the Islamic Library and other Iraqi cultural institutions has given way to disgust at the United States’ failure to protect the collection’s invaluable artifacts. The museum’s collection was devastated.
Many are saying the United States failed to meet its obligations. The victorious armies are bound by the 1954 Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict to ensure that no harm comes to priceless artifacts like a collection of 40,000 limestone tablets covered in cuneiform script by the Sumerian and Babylonian cultures in around 3000 B.C.
Three U.S. cultural advisors resigned in protest against coalition forces failure to protect Iraq cultural artifacts.
“It didn't have to happen,” Martin Sullivan -- who headed the President's Advisory Committee on Cultural Property for eight years -- told Reuters news agency. "In a pre-emptive war, that's the kind of thing you should have planned for," he said.
Experts like McGuire Gibson, a professor at the Oriental Institute at the University of Chicago, say that they warned White House, State Department and Pentagon officials before the war began that military action in Iraq could result in looting and that the country's cultural sites and holy shrines must be protected.
Picking up the pieces
Archeologists, curators and art historians meeting under the aegis of the United Nations culture agency UNESCO in Paris on Thursday set to work to pick up the shards.
They are aiming to come up with a catalogue of the hundreds of thousands objects that were looted or destroyed. One catalogue in the National Museum was destroyed by looters, likely in an effort to cover tracks for the time when the pieces reach antiquities markets.
Experts believe that the plundering may have been commissioned, possibly by professionals, possibly from abroad. One indication was the fact that instead of breaking down the doors to the National Museum, someone seems to have had a key to let the looters in.
UNESCO has now called for a ban on the sale of the looted goods. It may have little effect though. Press reports say looted Iraqi artifacts have already been seen at markets in Teheran and Paris.
German Chancellor Merkel and Polish Prime Minister Tusk have vowed to help Ukraine, beginning with the swift signing of an EU association agreement. They also said they were preparing more sanctions against Moscow.
Reconnaissance flights and more joint exercises in Central Europe serve to reassure NATO members in the region, but critics say the crisis in Ukraine shows the alliance's relations with Russia need a dramatic rethink.
The Group of Seven industrialized nations has told Russia to halt Sunday's referendum aimed at annexing Crimea from Ukraine. The G7 says if Russia proceeds it will take "further action."
What is identity, and who has the right to define us? English Theatre Berlin poses these questions in the production, "Schwarz gemacht," an exploration into the Afro-German experience in 1938 Berlin.