1. Skip to content
  2. Skip to main menu
  3. Skip to more DW sites
PoliticsEurope

My Europe: How stronger alliances could benefit Europe

Radu Magdin
Radu Magdin
June 7, 2023

Closer cooperation between Poland, Romania, Ukraine and Moldova could bring huge benefits. However, for such an initiative to have a substantial impact, it must move beyond abstract aspirations, writes Radu Magdin.

https://p.dw.com/p/4SESH
Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki (left) and Romanian President Klaus Iohannis shake hands at the presidential palace in Bucharest, March 28, 2023
During a visit to Bucharest in March, Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki (left, shaking hands with Romanian President Klaus Iohannis) proposed a triangle of closer cooperation between Poland, Romania and UkraineImage: picture alliance/dpa/AP

In recent years, there has been growing momentum toward building stronger alliances and cooperation in Central and Eastern Europe. As some have argued, particularly in the context of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, power in Europe is shifting to the East.

The proposal put forward by Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki in Bucharest in March 2023 to develop a triangle of cooperation between Poland, Romania and Ukraine holds great potential for advancing regional security, economic prosperity and strategic influence. The strategic significance of the proposed triangle is undeniable.

Poland and Romania, as NATO members on the eastern flank, have a shared understanding of the challenges posed by Russia's aggressive conduct in the region and are united by a strategic partnership and great economic potential.

Meeting of the Bucharest Nine (B9) and US President Joe Biden at the presidential palace in Warsaw on February 22, 2023
Poland and Romania — both countries on NATO's eastern flank — are already cooperating closely within the Bucharest Nine (B9) groupImage: MANDEL NGAN/AFP

Their collaboration within the Bucharest Nine (B9) group — which is made up of NATO members Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, the Czech Republic, Hungary and Slovakia — has proven fruitful in addressing these security concerns, coordinating with the United States and amplifying their voices in Washington.

A potentially formidable alliance of four

By extending this partnership to include Ukraine and potentially Moldova (a key priority for Bucharest), the resulting rectangle could create a formidable alliance capable of addressing regional security threats and reaping the economic benefits of a common market with a population of 100 million.

Enhanced cooperation between Poland, Romania, Ukraine and Moldova would bring numerous advantages. Firstly, it would foster closer economic integration and trade, creating a new economic community in Central and Eastern Europe.

The foundation has already been laid

It is worth noting that Romania has already set up a trilateral format with Moldova and Ukraine, thus laying a foundation of cooperation that could serve a greater purpose. Yet a rectangular collaboration could attract more investments, promote economic growth and unlock the untapped potential of the region.

Ukrainian Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal (left) and Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki shake hands next to the first Leopard 2 tanks delivered from Poland, undisclosed location in Ukraine, February 24, 2023
'Poland and Romania should use their voices to advocate for more and faster Western military support for Ukraine,' writes Radu MagdinImage: Ukrainian Governmental Press Service/REUTERS

Additionally, joint infrastructure projects — such as transport networks and energy pipelines — would enhance connectivity and facilitate the movement of goods and people. This increased connectivity could strengthen economic ties, stimulate innovation and boost competitiveness in the global market.

This year, Romania will host the Three Seas Initiative Summit (3SI) and the 3SI Business Forum, which will give these countries the opportunity to show that they really do mean business — in the truest sense of the word.

Promoting democratic values

From a political standpoint, this rectangle could provide a platform for promoting democratic values and good governance. EU member Poland (hopefully, after fixing its tense relationship with Brussels) and Romania have valuable experience to share with Ukraine and Moldova on their path toward European integration.

People holding EU and Moldovan flags at a rally called by President Maia Sandu, aiming to show the country's support for EU accession, Great National Assembly Square, Chisinau, Moldova, May 21, 2023
A pro-EU rally in the capital, Chisinau, in May demonstrated the strong popular support in Moldova for the country's accession to the EUImage: Aurel Obreja/AP Photo/picture alliance

The exchange of knowledge, best practice and technical assistance could help accelerate political and institutional reforms in these countries, ultimately bringing them closer to the European Union. This would not only benefit the aspiring nations, but also contribute to stability in the wider region and invalidate the narrative that liberal democracy is losing ground in Central and Eastern Europe.

However, there are potential factors and elements that could hinder a fruitful engagement within this rectangle.

Obstacles on the road ahead

One major challenge is the ongoing war in Ukraine. The unresolved conflict poses a significant obstacle to cooperation, as it creates a hostile environment and raises security concerns. Any successful initiative would require a concerted effort to find a peaceful resolution and ensure stability in the region.

Poland and Romania should use their voices to advocate for more and faster Western military support for Ukraine, so that Kyiv can liberate the occupied territories this year.

Diverging interests and priorities

Another obstacle lies in the divergent interests and priorities of the participating countries. While Poland and Romania share similar security concerns, Ukraine and Moldova face unique geopolitical challenges.

Images of the flags of Ukraine (left) and Moldova (right) superimposed on the EU flag to symbolize the fact that Moldova and Ukraine were granted EU candidate status in 2022
'EU members Poland and Romania have valuable experience to share with Ukraine and Moldova on their path toward European integration,' writes Radu Magdin Image: Andre M. Chang/ZUMAPRESS/picture alliance

Irrespective of the outcome of the war, Ukraine will continue to deal with a revisionist Russia that will do whatever it can to undermine a Euro-Atlantic path for Kyiv and destabilize the rules-based international order.

Russian attempts to destabilize Moldova

Moldova is a key target for Russian destabilization attempts, with Moscow using hybrid techniques to seek to overthrow Moldova's pro-European government. Fortunately, for now, the strong popular support for European integration keeps these attempts at bay.

Overcoming these challenges and aligning strategic objectives could be complex and require not only a redesign of the European security architecture, but also massive economic resources and investments.

Concrete projects are key

To ensure the sustainability and success of this initiative, it is crucial to match its strategic value with concrete projects. Merely expressing intentions and aspirations will not be sufficient.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy (left) shakes hands with Moldovan President Maia Sandu as they arrive at the European Political Community (EPC) Summit in Bulboaca, Moldova, June 1, 2023
Ukraine and Moldova face unique geopolitical challengesImage: Ludovic Marin/AFP/Getty Images

The rectangle should focus on swiftly agreeing on a list of key projects and implementing tangible initiatives that deliver practical benefits to all parties involved. These could include joint ventures in energy, infrastructure, technology, agriculture and other sectors. By demonstrating tangible outcomes, it could attract further support and gain strategic momentum.

Toward a flourishing Central and Eastern Europe

In terms of business potential, the rectangle offers vast opportunities. The participating countries have diverse economies, skilled workforces and strategic locations that could attract investment and foster entrepreneurship. By facilitating trade, removing barriers and harmonizing regulations, it could create a favorable business environment that encourages innovation, job creation and economic growth.

What Russia fears most — namely a prosperous Ukraine and an Eastern Europe where people live significantly better than in Moscow — could thus become reality.

By implementing tangible initiatives that deliver practical economic, political and security benefits, this triangle could foster regional integration, enhance stability and unlock the immense business potential of Central and Eastern Europe.

With a commitment to collaboration, a focus on shared interests and a determination to overcome challenges, this strategic East has the potential to reshape and eventually pacify the region.

Radu Magdin is a global Romanian analyst, consultant and former prime ministerial adviser in Romania and Moldova.

Edited by: Aingeal Flanagan